The Rare Review

Movies, books, music and TV

Pat Garrett And Billy The Kid (Big Deal)

Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid

Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Flecks of disrespect toward people who profess to be Christians are found in some of Sam Peckinpah‘s movies (The Deadly Companions, Ride the High Country), and clearly Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid (1973) is no exception.  (I’ll give Straw Dogs a pass; it’s different).  But Christians need not be offended by Garrett:  the entire film is unloved pig vomit, not to be taken seriously.

It is easy to mistake the picture for a Bob Dylan musical, with bad songs aplenty—Dylan wrote the, uh, score—but, no, it is of course a Western.  This one, though, is not much enlivened by its scenes of violent action, gripping as these can be.  When it isn’t ludicrous, the material is tired.  The film is inert. . . As many as six film editors worked on it, with Peckinpah typically denied further control of the flick.  If only screenwriter Rudy Wurlitzer had been denied any control of it.

Don’t Forget “Remember the Night”

Re “Remember the Night” (1939):

“Love blooms between a sympathetic attorney and the comely shoplifter he has taken home for the Christmas holiday” (imdb.com).

And so it does, in a script by Preston Sturges directed by Mitchell Leisen. Lee Leander (Barbara Stanwyck), the shoplifter, is a crook eventually ready to be reformed. Prosecutor John Sergent (Fred MacMurray) is good at his job but no blackguard. After paying Lee’s bail, he takes her to his hometown for Christmas and lodging; and like his mother and his aunt, he recognizes the shoplifter’s humanity (not hard to do). The hometown is in Indiana. The film is unsentimental about Middle America, just as it is about New York City; but it’s terrifically humane.

Some agreeable histrionic work goes on here, especially from Willard Robertson—vivid as Lee’s defense attorney. Except for its condescending attitude toward John’s black servant, “Night” is a quite nice tragic comedy, or rather pathos-comedy. There is no real tragedy here, and a few laughs can be had.

“A Summer with Monika”: A Summer With Sweater Girl

Summer with Monika

Summer with Monika (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

A Summer with Monika (1953) is a Swedish film directed by Ingmar Bergman from a novel by Per Anders Fogelstrom.

Monika (Harriet Andersson), for a long time a believable character, and Harry (Lars Ekberg), not much explored, are two adolescent lovers.  Both are inexperienced and foolish but also harassed and even mistreated.  Eventually they marry, but in the film’s final third, unfortunately, Bergman allows Monika to become a surprising tramp.  This is, nonetheless, one of the Swede’s few successful movies, remarkably made with its wonderful exterior shots, long takes and (of course) mise en scene.

In addition, it is a famously erotic film—and not just for 1953—with Andersson exposing her very pretty buttocks.  She is an actress so “natural” it is uncanny, as true in her hysteria as in everything else.  She creates a good blending of sophistication and innocence, and is enticingly kinetic.  It is a great performance in a more-than-okay movie.

(In Swedish with English subtitles)

 

 

 

Crime Of Old: “The Suspect”

What does a man in Edwardian England do when his marriage is hopeless?  Well, he should not fall in love with another woman.  This is what Philip Marshall in The Suspect (1944) does, and his outraged wife, Margaret Hamilton as the Wicked Witch of the West, refuses to give him a divorce.  The presence of young Mary, Philip’s love interest, keeps him in town and makes him desperate.  Ergo he kills his wife, in a murder  plot not exactly believable.  Very easily he becomes The Suspect.

This Robert Siodmak film is an Old Hollywood crime story set in Old London.  In polished black and white, it isn’t anything important but it is entertaining enough, what with, for one thing, Charles Laughton in the leading part.  Rosalind Ivan is good and true as the shrewish wife, and although I regard Ella Raines as perfectly passable as Mary, I wish Universal had hired a Brit, not an American, for the role.  Not bloody likely:  other women in the film are American too.

(Seen on YouTube)

Nifty “Housekeeping”

In Bill Forsyth‘s film “Housekeeping” (1987), following the suicide of their mother, two young sisters begin life anew, often discontentedly, with a friendly but eccentric aunt, Sylvie. The piece is thoughtful and never pretentiously directed or acted. I don’t know what Marilynn Robinson’s novel, the movie’s source, is actually about, but the film is about lives that are threadbare. This is a theme, and so is that of self-improvement which life of the young understandably demands. . . Forsyth said the movie is “a commercial to get people to read the novel.” A humble opinion. But despite its story not being consistently expert, “Housekeeping”‘s acting by Christine Lahti (Sylvie) and other thespians makes it rather more than such a commercial.

Page 1 of 320

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén