Movies, books, music and TV

Author: EarlD Page 5 of 304

The Heights? The “Wuthering Heights” Movie

Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights is a brilliant novel, even though I have never much explored its meaning, which I perhaps wouldn’t like. The 1970 British cinematic version of it, directed by Robert Fuest, is not very faithful to the book and thus doesn’t yield any real meaning. It’s just a romantic period piece whose Heathcliff (Timothy Dalton) is not the vengeful moral monster of the novel but a pretty enigmatic outsider. However, to be sure, he is not a good man and yet at the end the film glorifies him. A mistake.

Still, I don’t regret seeing Heights. It has some lovely actresses and is attractive-looking. Anna Calder-Marshall, a frequent TV actress, is wholly admirable as Cathy Earnshaw. Judy Cornwell is beautifully persuasive as a maid named Nellie. Certain elements in the film make it plainly more interesting than successful.

No Dessert Of Love In Mauriac’s “The Desert of Love” – A Book Review

“You can’t compare yourself to God.”

“Am I not God’s image in your eyes?  Is it not to me that you owe your taste for a certain kind of perfection?”

This exchange of words does not take place except in the imagination of Dr. Paul Courreges, the main figure in the Francois Mauriac novel The Desert of Love (1925), which exchange is between Courreges and the woman he has long been passionate about (and it ain’t his wife): Maria Cross.  Doubtless Maria is the kind of woman to see “God’s image” in a man she falls for, but Courreges, it turns out, is not that man.  Yet the doctor still loves Maria, whereas she gradually falls for Courreges’s son Raymond.  What the novel directs us to is, on the one hand, the deep secularization of French society and, on the other, “the desert of love” one encounters after connections are made with the desired person.

Very little is working out for these characters, and not a one of them adheres, as Mauriac did, to any particular religion.  The Desert of Love is very solemn and even tragic, though with Christian overtones.  Although God is seldom mentioned in the book, when He is, the references are not only sobering but also encouraging.  Example: “There could be no hope for either of them, for father or for son, unless, before they died, He should reveal Himself Who, unknown to them, had drawn and summoned from the depths of their beings this burning, bitter tide.”

To think that God would summon from a person a burning, bitter tide!  I was prompted to use the word “encouraging” for a reason.

 

Cover of "The Desert of Love"

Cover of The Desert of Love

“Skirt Day” Pulls No Punches About French Society

The France wherein jihadists have slaughtered innocents is the France of the 2008 film, Skirt Day—a scathing picture indeed.

Here, Sonia, a public high school teacher who often wears skirts, is trying to teach a drama course to wild, disrespectful immigrant kids from Muslim backgrounds.  (They hate skirts.)  Astonished to find that a thuggish African boy has a pistol in his possession, Sonia grabs it and is badly bullied for her trouble.  Now in shock—and feeling vindictive—she unintentionally shoots the boy in the leg and takes the students hostage, though only with the aim of delivering this day’s school lesson.  A police detective, Labouret, is sent to investigate and remedy the situation.  Sonia’s estranged husband, too, arrives at the school, enraged at the principal who has long failed to adequately help Sonia with discipline problems.

The film tells us that Muslim boys have learned to be misogynistic, and even misogynistic criminals.  They also use the word “kike.”  French society here is choking on its racial-ethnic insanity but, what is more, it witnesses the awful weakening of the institutions of school and marriage—and of French customs.  The result is that people feel deracinated and fretful.  Labouret, for example, understands that his marriage is at an end.  Personal angst is running high.

The director-writer is Jean-Paul Lilienfeld (talented), the actress who plays Sonia is Isabelle Adjani (talented—and superlative here).  The film’s climax is not that good, but everything else is dramatically skillful and unspeakably provocative, with a sprinkling of bitter humor.  Skirt Day may be the most politically honest and disturbing French artwork since The Camp of the Saints.

(In French with English subtitles)

La journée de la jupe

La journée de la jupe (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Teacher Want A Kiss? “A Teacher”

Diana Watts is A Teacher (high school; Austin, Texas), with a nice body and a nice high-school boyfriend, Eric, selected from her class. They sleep together, and Diana is fearful that she will be caught and lose her job. But she doesn’t want to lose Eric either.

A question springs up: Is Diana a monster of irresponsibility? Her brother apparently thinks she is neglecting their mother, who seems to have some form of dementia. And eventually she is consumed with emotional need, turning into a basket case.

This 2013 indie film was written and directed by Hannah Fidell. As Diana, Lindsay Burdge shows a perfect understanding of her character’s personality. She is never overwrought and Fidell, for her part, shoots her, including her nudity, with wise discretion. It’s a quite effective item, with too many scenes, perhaps, with short-running dialogue. But I don’t mind that A Teacher is a short-running film, at an hour and 15 minutes long.

(Available on Freevee and Tubi)

Boy Trouble: “Lord of the Flies”

A prominent critic opined that in writing Lord of the Flies, William Golding created merely a situation, not a novel. Well, to be sure, Peter Brook‘s film adaptation of the Golding book (from 1963) is not a very novelistic movie and doesn’t have to be. Rather it’s an opus of visual potency. The problem, however, is that it isn’t very well directed. Brook under-emphasizes important points and fails to create a good narrative flow. The young male actors in Flies play schoolboys marooned on an island who become foolish and vengeful brutes, but the performers seem lost, their acting unfocused. The killing of a boy named Simon (Tom Gaman) is ugly but clumsy. The blame falls on Brook. Would that the Francois Truffaut who directed The 400 Blows had made this film.

Page 5 of 304

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén